Members of a school district advisory committee warned of a coming "train wreck" as an estimated 144,000 square feet of school facilities, which includes portions of four schools, will need to be replaced in the next five years.
It was the second report of the advisory board, which is made up of representatives from the district, the city and the real estate industry, since its inception in 2006.
A report presented in August 2007 focused on new facilities needs as the city grows toward projected build out in 2020.
This report examined the adequacy and life expectancy of existing facilities. Advisory board members evaluated each of the district's nine school sites based on nine criteria, including the quality of the buildings and facilities, adequacy of parking, room for expansion, proximity to other schools and access for traffic and buses.
Up to 10 points were awarded for each factor. Starline Elementary School received the lowest rating, with 18 points. Lake Havasu High School received the highest rating of 64.
The report concluded that nearly half the district's square footage, or more than 400,000 square feet, would need to be replaced in the next 15 years.
"The big push is new schools, but you’ve got a much bigger problem of aging and deterioration of your existing schools, and that will happen whether you get more students or not," advisory board member Darrel Williams, an independent engineering contractor, told the board.
The state's School Facilities Board, which pays for the construction of public school facilities, calculates the life expectance of a masonry building to be 40 to 50 years, depending on maintenance.
Williams said that because the school maintenance has been funded at 50 to 60 percent of what it should be, the advisory board assumed the lower life expectancy of 40 years.
Starline and Havasupai elementary schools, Daytona Middle School and the original buildings at Lake Havasu High School are approaching that age.
"You have a train wreck coming at you. It's avoidable, but it's going to take some hard work and planning to avoid it," Williams said.
Advisory board members encouraged the governing board to begin preparing now for a future application to the SFB for funding to replace aging schools. That would have to include a formal study of the structures by architects and engineers, Williams said.
"We have noticed most of the school districts, if they have their planning in place and are ready to go, they will get (funded)," said advisory board member Joe Stella, the district's maintenance supervisor.
Stella said the SFB, which was formed by the Legislature in 1998, hasn't yet dealt with the issue of replacing schools. It was created to provide equitable funding for new schools, particularly in the rapidly growing Phoenix metropolitan area.
If the district is well prepared with its request for replacement facilities, it could take the lead in helping the SFB develop new procedures, Stella said.
You may contact the reporter at dparker@havasunews.com.

Article Rating