Parker Pioneer Stocks Orchids & Onions Obituaries Calendar Weather Public Notices Archives Clip n' Save Coupons
Weather Magnet

City looking for new finance director

By NATHAN BRUTTELL
Today's News-Herald
Published Tuesday, February 16, 2010 11:23 PM MST

The city’s new finance director won’t need to worry about an expected $3.8 million in cuts needed for this year’s budget formation as current finance director Gayle Whittle will stay with the city until April.


The city is currently looking to fill Whittle’s position, as she expects to retire April 16. Whittle originally planned to retire earlier, but decided to stay with the city in order to help form the city’s financial budget. Initial budget discussions are under way, including paring down about $3.8 million in necessary cuts for the coming year. Whittle said the firing of former city manager Richard Kaffenberger in October also contributed to her decision.

“I knew this was going to be a very difficult budget season,” she said. “I knew it was going to be a difficult transition for the city to have a new interim city manager (Charlie Cassens) and a new finance director.”

The city’s notice states the position requires a “bachelor’s degree in finance or accounting with nine years of progressively responsible public-sector finance experience, including four years at the management level. A master’s degree and (certified public accountant) is highly desirable.” The position is expected to have an annual salary range of $101,000 to $116,000.

Cassens said he expects most of the budget work will be completed before Whittle retires.

“By that time, we hope to have most of the difficult work completed on the budget and we’ll be in the position of doing mostly fine-tuning for the final adoption,” he said. “We have staff onboard now working on the budget so the budget is not a worry. We really appreciate the fact that Gayle was willing to stay to help us with it.”

Candidates must apply for the position by March 19. Cassens added the position might not be filled by April 16.

“There is a very good possibility that we’d have to go a few weeks or a month or so without a department director,” he said. “Naturally we’d like to have someone come on as quickly as possible, but with a nationwide search, it’s very likely a candidate might not be available right away.”

Whittle said she feels very comfortable with the finance department staff handling the transition.

“We have several long-tenured employees who are really going to be able to help with things and any changes,” she said. “I can’t say enough about the finance department staff. They are all very dedicated, very hardworking and care about the city a lot. I think over the years, they’ve helped me look good and I couldn’t have done half the things we did without them.”

Whittle said she was proud of her work with the wastewater system expansion program and ensuring the city had a plan for future sustainability.

“(The sewer project) probably took a great deal of my time and was probably my most significant achievement,” she said, adding that the project was made easier with the coordination of the City Council, the Public Works Department and other city staff. “We all worked to define a great plan that would have the least impact to residents on a monthly basis.”

Whittle said she accomplished many of her goals in her five years with the city.

“We came up with a system for longer range planning for the budget process and setting sustainable fiscal policies for city,” she said. “I think the city is in a great position going into the future and I’m glad I was a part of that.”

Whittle previously worked for the city from 1990 to 1996, before accepting a job in Utah and working as Bullhead City’s finance director. She has been with Lake Havasu City as the finance director since 2005. For her retirement, Whittle said she plans on moving to the Phoenix metropolitan area to spend more time with her children and grandchildren and said she will keep busy with volunteer work.

You can contact the reporter at nbruttell@havasunews.com

Article Rating

    Current Rating: 4 of 1 votes!Rate File:

Comments (38 comment(s))

    o'really wrote on Mar 1, 2010 9:12 PM:

    " ya Havasu will be fine, but lonely after we allow our Magistrate to run off all our tourists and ruin our reputation even more "

    Desertrat wrote on Feb 28, 2010 9:30 AM:

    " longtime - Right on. Those who enjoy their lives (problems and all) will continue to do so, while those who don't -will continue to whine and complain on the internet. "

    longtimeinhavasu wrote on Feb 27, 2010 8:27 AM:

    " To all of you naysayers and pessimistic bloggers, Havasu will be fine, the citizens will be fine, and eventually, you all will be fine. I am glad you found the internet, othewise you would have had to sit and home stewing in your own thoughts. Now, with the internet, you can share them with a like minded minority while, day by day the rest of us put one foot in front of the other and move forward, hard working and optimistic. Been here to long, seen it all. Life is good, have a nice day. "

    dudu2 wrote on Feb 26, 2010 11:41 PM:

    " It is very har to get a job for more than $40,000 in this town unless you are working for the goverment. The goverment employees regulate us and force us to pay more taxes from less and less money while their salary skyrocketing.
    I also loved the fact, that the communication director took over the city manager's job and nobody is missing him in his old job. Tha mayor needs to cut this position and save some money! "

    tiredofbunk wrote on Feb 26, 2010 3:26 PM:

    " I think you all forget that they just fired one of worst managers ever who intimidated every employee. I think you all also forget that this collapse and mis-management happpened right under the mayors nose who is a CPA. Hmmm "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 26, 2010 7:40 AM:

    " oldone,

    I'm not blaming Ms. Whittle alone by any means. I'm merely pointing out she is the one that had first hand knowledge of what the situation looked like and the expertise to interpret those results, she was the captain of the ship. The problem is, she like so many others are so worried about being politically correct and following protocol that you now have a situations like we are in now. She warned about the financial problems, so her conscience was clear, the city council was too weak to stand up to the special interests in town. The result, Havasu on the brink of complete collapse. Again, as is always the case, when city government becomes your largest employer, your town will fail every single time. And why? Because you can't print currency and she knows this and she did the bare minimum to warn the citizens about what was coming and now she's leaving. "

    oldone wrote on Feb 25, 2010 10:44 PM:

    " johnjay as early as 2005 Mrs Whittle told the then Council of the short fall and the pending problems. She also reminded them of the city statute for recovering moneys for city services. Even the consultent reports gave a gloom and doom future. The then council and those that followed, still went ahead with budgets that had fat in them. Such as all the special intrest groups. So I don't put blame on her alone . And why not retire as she is no different then anyone else. Look at all the Congress and Senators quiting in Washington, as they will get a nice retirement also. "

    LakeLizard wrote on Feb 25, 2010 9:46 AM:

    " If Wall Street will have me I will be there....coolbridge must work for the city there or else he/she would not have so much time...try self employment the biggest headache is dealing with different government entities...lazy, unmotivated, and unhelpful "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 24, 2010 9:40 AM:

    " I really only have one question for Ms. Whittle, are the citizens of Lake Havasu better off now than they were when Ms. Whittle took this position? The citizens can make their own judgment as to her performance. By the way if Ms. Whittle was so astute as to recognize that Havasu was running a deficit that it could not sustain or was taking on debt that would cripple its very existence why didn't she resign under moral protest and inform the citizens of the dire financial situation the city was facing. It wasn't until Havasu started this epic melt down that she decided to "retire". Again not the actions of a superb person, more like rats leaving the sinking ship, I suspect as this gets worse you'll see additional resignations from our bureaucrats as they decide to take the money and run. And alas the business owners and property owners, those who put their nose to the grind stone and build good old American wealth and create productive jobs, will be left to rebuild what they have destroyed. "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 23, 2010 11:45 PM:

    " "I suspect that most of the people that have negative comments about this job/article do not have the ambition it takes to better yourselves." Again your city check book is 18 million dollars in the red, not the definition of a superb job. I'm just in awe how little respect these government workers have for those that pay their salary. So people like Mr. Shugrue or Mr. Flatley or Mr. Reed or Mr. Campbell or any of the hundreds of other entrepreneurs who build businesses, create jobs and invest in the city are uneducated and lazy and haven't thought out their future because they didn't take a corporate job or work for the government. Let's see how long your government jobs last when the entrepreneurs decide it's not worth putting the effort into building business. "

    O'really wrote on Feb 23, 2010 10:55 PM:

    " fact, Lake Havasu is requiring a degree to be the chief check writer, and does not require it to be the chief fine giver.

    Gayle, you have done a great job in the service the city and deserve nothing but accolades, it shows what a great service someone with a degree can do.

    It is too bad the city does not require that the chief fine giver be as at least as qualified as those who appear before him to accuse others of crimes (the prosecutor) or those who defend the accused (the defense). I would think that the person hearing the arguement should be as at least as educated as those making the arguements.

    Coolbridge makes an excellent case why the current council members should not be reelected for thier part in rehiring the current chief fine giver after he was reprimanded. "

    beenthere wrote on Feb 23, 2010 8:11 AM:

    " I always get a kick out of the people that criticize hard working people who have educated themselves, planned for their future and have done well in their life. I defy any of you out there to take the responsibility that Gayle has had and do as good a job without her background and education. You make GOOD money if you have erned it. I suspect that most of the people that have negative comments about this job/article do not have the ambition it takes to better yourselves. Yes, there are acceptions to this comment, but look around. If you get an education, pay your dues through the years, plan for your future, and get a good job, you do not have to live off of the entitlement programs that people like Gayle pay for out of her 100K plus salary. It wasn't Gayle who put the city in debt for the sewers. It was US, the tax payers. We voted overwhelmingly for it. The fedral government is also responsible for the "unfunded mandates" that the city has to work under on a daily basis. Don't blame Gayle for the economy. She has done a GREAT job for the city. Thank you Gayle for your hard work and dedication. Enjoy your retirement, you deserve it.......... "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 23, 2010 7:54 AM:

    " Ok one more time CB, you have a finance manager that was responsible for the finances of the city of LH. She will be leaving that city on the verge of bankruptcy, and you're calling this a superb job. Do you see any flaw in your judgment? You're only response is she had no control over these outside influences. I assume you are saying that no matter who the finance manager, the city was destined to fail, I don't believe that. I'm sorry but based on past performance, I wouldn't hire her in any position of financial responsibility. Some how in her tenure at LH she failed to make the cities position better, maybe she wasn't strong enough or politically savvy enough to get her points across to the people that needed to be persuaded. It doesn't matter she is still leaving a city in financial failure. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 23, 2010 6:46 AM:

    " Now that JJ/LL/NB has been vanquished, here's something I found on the courts. Back | AJB | Sitemap | Search

    The Structure of Arizona's Judiciary

    Limited Jurisdiction Courts

    Municipal Courts

    Many incorporated cities or towns have a municipal court, also known as a city court or magistrate court. Municipal courts have criminal jurisdiction over misdemeanor crimes and petty offenses committed in their city or town. They share jurisdiction with justice courts over violations of state law committed within their city or town limits.

    Municipal court judges (magistrates) hear misdemeanor criminal traffic cases such as driving under the influence of alcohol, hit-and-run and reckless driving where no serious injuries occur. They hear civil traffic cases, violations of city ordinances and codes, and issue orders of protection and injunctions prohibiting harassment. They can also issue search warrants. They DO NOT hear civil lawsuits between citizens.

    City charters or ordinances establish the qualifications of these judges. Some cities do not require municipal court judges to be attorneys. City or town councils appoint their judges, except in Yuma, where municipal court judges are elected. Judges serve terms set by the city or town council; their terms must be at least two years.

    Judges have court clerks who provide clerical assistance and schedule cases. In larger cities, the judges may also have court administrators.

    Justice of the Peace Courts

    Each county’s board of supervisors sets the geographical boundaries, known as precincts, of that county’s justice of the peace courts. Generally, these precincts are larger than city or town limits and typically incorporate an entire city or town, and pieces of other communities as well. Although these geographical boundaries can be changed, the precincts cannot be abolished until the four year term of the current justice of the peace expires.

    Justice of the peace courts hear traffic cases and certain criminal and civil cases, including domestic violence and harassment cases. They can issue search warrants. Their civil jurisdiction is limited to cases involving claims less than $10,000.

    Justice courts share jurisdiction with the superior court in cases of landlord/tenant disputes where damages are between $5,000 and $10,000. They can hear matters regarding possession of, but not title to, real property. Disputes involving amounts greater than $10,000 must be filed in the superior court.

    When conducting preliminary hearings on felonies, justice court judges may require defendants to answer criminal charges in superior court. They also may dismiss charges if there is no probable cause to believe the defendant is guilty.

    Justice courts have criminal jurisdiction over:

    petty offenses and misdemeanors;
    assault or battery — less serious offenses not committed on a public officer while performing his or her duties;
    breaches of peace and committing a willful injury to property;
    misdemeanors and criminal offenses punishable by fines not more than $2,500, or imprisonment in county jail, not more than six months, or both fine and imprisonment; and,
    felonies for the purpose of issuing warrants and conducting preliminary hearings.

    Court Personnel

    Most justice of the peace precincts have an elected constable. The constable’s duties are to execute, serve and return all processes and legal documents as directed by the court. Some statutes relating to sheriffs also govern the powers, duties and liabilities of constables.

    The justice of the peace usually has one or more court clerks to provide clerical assistance and maintain court records. Additionally, justice courts in some busy urban precincts have a court administrator.

    Justice of the Peace Qualifications

    A justice of the peace:
    Is elected to a four year term;
    Must be at least 18 years old;
    Must be an Arizona resident;
    Must be a qualified voter in the precinct in which duties of office will be performed;
    Must read and write English; and,
    Need not be an attorney.

    So clue me in, remember facts only, no emotion, talk of censure needs time, place why, result, documentation, etc. Please...Please clarity of thought, and address each issue, none of JJ/LL/NB throw a bunch of nonsense and hope something sticks. "

    desertrat wrote on Feb 22, 2010 9:34 PM:

    " Yeah, and all this wonderful bashing of our city on the newspaper forum is great for our reputation. Can't place all the blame on one person or the courts. You haters do a fine job of running people off. But we will see, we will see....let's see how many people DON"T line the channel this spring break. And let's see IF all your bashing really makes a CHANGE in government. "

    o'really wrote on Feb 22, 2010 3:16 PM:

    " anything to avoid discussing the facts and issues Johnjay or LL or NM brought up.
    All three have great points and so did DM.
    Coolbridge, are you saying that you do find it odd that a degree is required to be the towns checkwriter but not the person who can put people in jail?
    I think that any department head should be well qualified, and to get somebody with an MBA we better offer 100K. We better get a good one with the rate the Mag is flushing our reputation down the toilet. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 22, 2010 11:08 AM:

    " I was using a technique called ridiculing. Let us review what JJ/LL/NB used. 1) Coolbridge, spoken like a true tax taker, you look down upon those that pay with their hard labor. 2)infrastructure in complete disarray and she's retiring on Havasu money 3)Ms. Whittle is an innocent bystander and has little influence on the financial position Havasu is in. 4)coolbridge your arrogance is how people know your a tax taker 5)when I return you will eat those words. 6)you sound like a little 13 year old girl 7)they werent good enough for the fortune 1000 so they have to stick it to the little guy under the guise of civil service. 8) the voters of Havasu are dumb as rocks Let us review mine. 1) " What's your next screen name? JJ/LL/NB " 2) There are none so blind as those who will not see. " 3)So are you sending your resume to Fortune 1000 companies or is The Twilight Zone marathon running? " #3 was a good one, yeah, that was funny. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 22, 2010 10:14 AM:

    " JJ/LL/NB, you make me laugh, thanks. By the way how was The Twilight Zone marathon? "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 22, 2010 8:41 AM:

    " "Somehow the couch potatoes and lazy loafers think they hold the moral high ground due to their failures." Based on your expressed opinions, I assume those you are speaking about are all those who neither work in government positions or work for a large corporation. Also, one more little bit of advise, personal attacks against your fellow debaters is a weak form of debate, it makes you sound like a little 13 year old girl and dismisses any credibility your arguments may contain. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 22, 2010 6:59 AM:

    " What's your next screen name? JJ/LL/NB "

    DesertMouse wrote on Feb 21, 2010 10:39 PM:

    " nomore, great post!
    So the city now requires a professional degree to basically balance the check book of the city but it does not require a degree to balance the scales of Justice? To be finance director you must have the most professional degree in the building but to be a Magistrate everyone else in the room may have the professional degree but he is expected to be able to sort through the issues..... "

    northbound wrote on Feb 21, 2010 9:30 AM:

    " sure hope who ever gets this job does some good for a change, sorry but I don't see where any one has done a great job look at how far in debt we are. Again start cutting wages for a change begin at the top of the food chain. How many of you working for the city would like to keep your job and bennies just take a cut in pay? I would think several would be rather greatful they can still put food on the table. I don't want to hear about how these days people with degrees don't come cheap, people with so called experience need to be thankful they can even get a job still and should be expecting to get paid some what less then what they think they are worth now a days times are far to bad to cry hey I'm smart I have a degree pay me through the nose. I would like to see all these top city officials step up to the plate and take a large cut in pay for one year lets see what a difference that will make in our debt. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 20, 2010 9:11 AM:

    " If that were true your posts would have less emotion, show some evidence of fact and research, and not end with a threat. So are you sending your resume to Fortune 1000 companies or is The Twilight Zone marathon running? "

    LakeLizard wrote on Feb 19, 2010 8:27 PM:

    " my J.D. is only 3 semesters away, and when I return you will eat those words. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 19, 2010 4:15 PM:

    " It always amazes me how successful people are called arrogant and useless by some people in this country. Hard work and education leads to higher wages and positions of power. Somehow the couch potatoes and lazy loafers think they hold the moral high ground due to their failures. A great many of these people cut their teeth in big companies, and bring vast experience with them. Doors, guys like lake lizard could not open. Arrogance and pride in being a loser would be your moniker not mine. "

    oldone wrote on Feb 19, 2010 3:17 PM:

    " WOW Don't you folks like anything in this town I mean Council, Police, Fireman, Any city worker etc. How many of you live here full time? Those that don't do you like the Goverment you have in your town? And do you vote. It is sad that you all have so little going on in your lives that you can't see any good in anything, not to say also how many do any work to make the city better? She has done a great job and dealing with the diferent Councils earned every penny.How would you like to manage your house hold money when your partner wants to spend spend, spend on all sorts of pet projects? If you would have spent time watching the budget meetings you would have seen her in action with the council. By the way the sewer was not on her watch she came in after the vote and has has to deal with it. Also the finance department has recieved many accounting awards since she has been here. "

    LakeLizard wrote on Feb 19, 2010 10:52 AM:

    " maybe just MAYBE...coolbridge your arrogance is how people know your a tax taker, besides the only people with these types of positions, I.E. City attorney, finance director, you name the position...well they werent good enough for the fortune 1000 so they have to stick it to the little guy under the guise of civil service . I remember the fear mongering they used about the sewer vote, dont you? "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 19, 2010 9:39 AM:

    " So JJ, as I expected you have no answers other than emotional drivel. Statements of facts and real understanding don't end with question marks. Thanks for playing. "

    JohnJay wrote on Feb 18, 2010 11:35 PM:

    " coolbridge,
    Ok, Ms. Gayle Whittle has done a superb job. It's some supreme outside force that caused the 18 million dollar deficit and the voters of Havasu are dumb as rocks for buying into this whole sewer thing, I see your position. "What infrastructure is in complete disarray?" You're kidding right? Glad to know Ms. Whittle is an innocent bystander and has little influence on the financial position Havasu is in. Hmmmm, seems like an awful lot of money to pay an innocent bystander with no real influence over the city financial situation? "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 18, 2010 5:31 PM:

    " So JJ, let me ask, liberal? Progressive? A quote from you, It takes a special kind of person to take $116K tax money when people are losing their house. You sound like President O talking to Joe the Plumber. Just spread that wealth around, never mind who works hard, who has educated themselves, give socialism a try. Nice. You seem to be a very emotional sort. Man..if only we had a minority or ethnic group to lay this on..oh, we do.. us,the citizens who neglected our civic responsibility and let things get out of control. Wake up, read, learn, vote on records not words, read the constitution, when's the last time you did that JJ. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 18, 2010 4:41 PM:

    " Well JJ, did she cause the 18 million deficit? No, that is from economic forces that have reduced the city's funding, lower sales taxes, etc. Did she impose the sewer costs? No, the voters of Havasu did by choosing that path. What infrastructure is in complete disarray? Don't try to say sewer as it is brand new. Her pension comes from a state plan, which she contributed to. She can retire where she wants. Your hatred and frustration has stopped rational thought. I like debate. But like dad always said, you can't have a battle of wits with an unarmed man. "

    JohnJay wrote on Feb 18, 2010 2:28 PM:

    " Superb???
    Coolbridge, spoken like a true tax taker, you look down upon those that pay with their hard labor. So let's see what the facts are, she's leaving with an 18 million dollar deficit, 1/2 billion dollar sewer bond that has to be paid for, an infrastructure in complete disarray and she's retiring on Havasu money spending it in Phoenix, did I miss anything, oh we taxpayers have to thank her, sorry. "

    coolbridge wrote on Feb 18, 2010 12:57 PM:

    " Yes, $116k a year was a lot for you depression era survivors but this is 80 years later. Go get a quarter from under the mattress, have lunch and take your girl to the ball game. People with that kind of education and accepting that kind of responsibility do not come cheap. Gayle has done a superb job for this city and deserves its thanks. I thank you Gayle. The fact is we will be lucky to get applicants of Gayle's quality at that price. There are none so blind as those who will not see. "

    johnjay wrote on Feb 18, 2010 6:07 AM:

    " Yep,

    You people are finally starting to get it, bureaucrats don't like to cut back even if it means they take every last dollar out of your retirement account, your child's college fund or make it so you can't afford health insurance. They don't even care if they tax you into foreclosure, just as long as they keep their lifestyle. It takes a special kind of person to take $116,000 of tax money when all your neighbors are losing their jobs and homes. "

    J.kendall wrote on Feb 17, 2010 6:54 PM:

    " I can't beleive the city is paying that much for a finance director that is just plain stupid. This possition should not even be over 70,000.00 a year maybe even less then that. "

    getoverit wrote on Feb 17, 2010 6:40 PM:

    " Ok is it just me or does any one else see whats wrong with this picture?
    (The position is expected to have an annual salary range of $101,000 to $116,000.) GOOD GRIEFF thats more then the last Sheriff I worked for who was making 93,000.00 a year. And the city is making more cuts at the police department cutting full time civil employee's vs the part time civil employee's to save from having to pay bennies. But your going to pay someone to sit behind a desk and decide what to do with our money over 81000.00 then a 911 dispatcher or over 63000.000 then an officer? I sure would like to know who decides how much the city finance director makes it's way too much to begin with. Maybe it's time to start cutting wages from the top of the hill. This job pays more them most chief of police in the state of AZ get. What are you people in those offices thinking? "

    nomore wrote on Feb 17, 2010 9:12 AM:

    " Le`ts see needs a degree to be finance manager? But you can decide the future of someones life with out one. why not put the old don`t need no stinking law degree judge in in there, then he can spend all the money he makes, destroy the town even faster and give it back to snakes. oh wait the snakes already have don`t thay "

    rosie wrote on Feb 17, 2010 8:23 AM:

    " Thanks for the great job! You are awesome. Enjoy your retirement. "

WRITE A COMMENT

Comment posters are responsible for the opinions they express and the accuracy of the information they provide. We urge comment writers to treat this as a public forum where manners matter. We encourage a collegial, non-insulting tone and we reserve the right to withhold or remove any comment from publication.

Do not post:
    * Potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.
    * Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
    * Personal attacks, insults or threats.
    * The use of another person's real name to disguise your identity.
    * Comments unrelated to the story.


Opinions, advice and all other information expressed in havasunews.com's story comments represent the individual's own views and not necessarily those of Today's News Herald. Today's News Herald provides an interactive computer service and does not endorse and is not responsible for statements, advice or opinions offered by anyone other than authorized Today's News Herald spokespersons.

Thank you for your comments!

You must register with a valid email to post comments. Only your Member ID will be posted with the comments.

Registered users sign in here:

Become a Registered User

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

*First Name:
*Last Name:
*Zip Code:
 
e-Edition

e-Edition

e-Edition

American Profile

Special Sections








View All Special Sections

Readers' Poll

Calendar

Stocks